Beginning of a Reformation in Islam? Not Yet

The right to pick one’s own religion and practice it freely, without fear of threat, intimidation, or even a death sentence for not practicing Islam is a freedom not found in many Islamic countries. In a hopeful sign, and quite possibly the first sign of a Reformation in Islam, comes word from Egypt that a fatwa has been issued on the matter:

Egypt’s official religious advisor has ruled that Muslims are free to change their faith as it is a matter between an individual and God, in a move which could have far-reaching implications for the country’s Christians.

“The essential question before us is can a person who is Muslim choose a religion other than Islam? The answer is yes, they can,” Grand Mufti Ali Gomaa said in a posting on a Washington Post-Newsweek forum picked up by the Egyptian press on Tuesday.

“The act of abandoning one’s religion is a sin punishable by God on the Day of Judgement. If the case in question is one of merely rejecting faith, then there is no worldly punishment,” he wrote.

In many Muslim societies, those who convert to another religion are considered apostates and can be subject to capital punishment.

Gomaa said that if the conversions undermine the “foundations of society” then it must be dealt with by the judicial system, without elaborating.

Attempts by Muslims in Egypt to convert to other religions have been hindered by the state’s refusal to recognise the change in official documents and in some cases have led to arrests and imprisonment.

“Even though it is not a criminal offence in Egypt, they get detained under emergency laws or are put on trial for contempt of religion if they wish to convert,” said Hossam Bahgat of the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights.

“This (ruling) is significant, especially coming from Gomaa,” he added. “Between 2004 and now there have been many court cases involving Christian converts to Islam that want to convert back to Christianity who are unable to do so.”

Bahgat, who is involved with a case of 12 former Christians who converted to Islam and are now trying to revert, said that Gomaa’s previous fatwas on the issue said apostasy threatened public order.

The current opinion opens the possibility of converting without threatening “the foundations of society.”

A spokesman for Dar al-Iftaa, the body headed by Gomaa which is responsible for issuing religious opinions, maintained that the mufti’s stance has not changed.

“The posting is consistent with the mufti’s past fatwas,” he told AFP. “Apostasy is only punishable when it is considered akin to subversion.”

The issue of apostasy is a thorny one in the Islamic world, with one extremist interpretation declaring that apostates should be killed.

“The punishment for apostasy is controversial,” judge Ahmed Mekky, the deputy head of Egypt’s Supreme Court, told AFP. “There is nothing in any Koranic text about this.”

Instead the texts talked about apostates who were put to death for treachery — a political rather than religious crime.

The case of the 12 Copts, whose request to revert was denied by a lower court in April, goes in front of the Supreme Court in September, and Bahgat said they will use Gomaa’s posting to bolster their case.

“Gomaa is a civil servant, the top religious advisor of the state, and technically speaking the deputy minister of justice,” he said. “So his views on the matter carry authority.” Source

I’m not holding my breath that this will be adopted worldwide. But a hopeful sign, very much indeed.

Update – Six Hours Later:

Cairo: Egypt’s top cleric yesterday denied in a statement that he had said a Muslim can give up his faith without punishment.Ali Goma’a, the mufti of Egypt, was quoted as saying in a posting on a Washington Post-Newsweek forum that Muslims are free to change their faith and this is a matter between an individual and God.

“What I actually said is that Islam prohibits a Muslim from changing his religion and that apostasy is a crime, which must be punished,” Goma’a said.

The alleged fatwa coincides with an uproar over the case of 12 Egyptians who converted to Islam from Christianity and now want to re-embrace Christianity.

“There is a campaign by secularists to distort the image of Dr Ali Goma’a,” a senior official in Al Azhar told Gulf News.

“He cannot deny punishment in this life for the apostate,” said Mustafa Al Chaka of the Islamic Research Centre. Source

So much for that Reformation movement. In other news today, the Pope announced the death penalty for all lapsed Catholics. No, he didn’t really.  There is only one religion/ideology on the face of this planet that can condemn non-believers to death. 

3 Responses to “Beginning of a Reformation in Islam? Not Yet”

  1. Slave of Allah Says:

    Islam is a religion that it is so great that everyone can join it by saying the Shahada ” I beware witness that there is NO GOD but ALLAH and I beware witness the Muhammad was his prophet” and if you are a christian then you can add the sentence ” And I beware witness that JEsus was a messenger of God”

    This is how easy to enter this great religion …. the religion that is so obvious and clear …. One God one Version of the Quran and still till now available the exact same ..with ZERO errors …and everything is clear…

    it is really amazing if u look with ur true heart to it how quickly u will revert to islam….

    Allah is the all merciful and the kind and the more compassion to his slaves ….

    it is the religion of peace and rest and satisfaction ….

    Try to learn about it and visit ur nearer mosque and see how happy and convinced u will be

    Peace be upon you all

    (Paleo: I don’t think I care to ‘revert’ or ‘beware witness’ right now. But thanks for the offer.)

  2. babbazee Says:

    Be vewwy vewwy qwiet

    Ahm Taqiyyawope huntin

  3. Karridine Says:

    Islam led to the Qaim (The Bab, the ‘Gate’ thru Whom the Lord of Hosts would come) and the Lord of the Age, the Mahdi, Baha’u’llah (The Glory of God).

    It is NOT easy to ‘overcome’ all the hurdles placed in the path of people seeking the righteousness that is Christ, today. He came at the time promices by Jesus (Matt 24:14, Luke 21:24, Matt 24:15); came in His New Name (Rev 2:17, 3:12) and lived among humankind the full 40 years prophesied by Micah (Micah 7:15)…

    But today is STILL the Day of Judgement: do we turn, heart and soul, in obedience TO the Promised One of All Religions?

    Or do we turn away, filled with our own selves, and “…show pride toward God from all eternity to all eternity?”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: